UrbanKisaanEnquire now

HomeResearchBreeding and genetics

Breeding and geneticsRice (Springer) · 2021

Transcriptomic evidence of distinct rice defence responses to brown and white-backed planthoppers

Brown and white-backed planthoppers attack rice together across Asia. Breeders often assume resistance to one covers the other. By reading which genes switch on and off under each pest, this study shows the defences are largely separate.

180rice lines tested against both pests
9,361genes changed under brown planthopper, 8,498 under white-backed
27key genes confirmed by real-time PCR

Research question

Does brown planthopper resistance in RP2068 also protect against white-backed planthopper?

Most breeding effort targets the brown planthopper, assuming those varieties also resist the white-backed planthopper. No study had compared how one resistant rice line defends itself against each pest at the level of genes.

Methods

180 TN1 × RP2068 RILs phenotyped; RNA-seq of RIL TR3RR after infestation; qRT-PCR validation of 27 genes

Three stages: cross, sequence, confirm.

  1. Cross180 inbred lines from a resistant (RP2068) by susceptible (TN1) cross, each tested against both pests.
  2. SequenceRead every active gene in a resistant line after attack by each pest, against uninfested plants.
  3. ConfirmCheck 27 key genes by PCR across five closely related lines.

Results

9,361 DEGs under BPH versus 8,498 under WBPH, most of them down-regulated

Resistance to the two pests segregated independently in the 180 lines, a sign of separate genes.

Figure 1

Genes switched on and off by each pest

Number of genes changed in the resistant line, compared with uninfested plants.

Switched offSwitched on
Brown planthopper
5,540
3,821
White-backed planthopper
4,402
4,096
Switched offSwitched on

Data: Results section of the paper.

Results

1,560 genes up-regulated and 2,308 down-regulated under both pests; 971 respond in opposite directions

Some defences are shared, such as trehalose and proline pathways; others are pest-specific, such as MYB-led defence against brown planthopper only.

Figure 2

Shared and pest-specific responses

Genes grouped by how they responded to each pest.

Off for both pests
2,308
On for both pests
1,560
Off for brown, on for white-backed
697
On for brown, off for white-backed
274
05001,0001,5002,0002,500

Data: Results section and Fig. 3 of the paper.

Implications

Resistance to the two planthoppers should be combined deliberately in breeding

Breeders should combine resistance to both pests on purpose, not expect one to bring the other. Pinning traits to genes is slow lab work. Aadi is built to predict which genes and alleles matter before the lab work starts.

See Aadi
180rice lines tested against both pests
9,361genes changed under brown planthopper, 8,498 under white-backed
27key genes confirmed by real-time PCR

The paper

RNA-Sequencing Reveals Differentially Expressed Rice Genes Functionally Associated with Defense against BPH and WBPH in RILs Derived from a Cross between RP2068 and TN1

Read the abstract

Rice is staple food for over two billion people. Planthoppers like BPH and WBPH occur together in most of rice growing regions across Asia and cause extensive yield loss by feeding and transmission of disease-causing viruses. Chemical control of the pest is expensive and ecologically disastrous; breeding resistant varieties is an acceptable option. But most of such efforts are focused on BPH with an assumption that these varieties will also be effective against WBPH. No critical studies are available to understand rice resistance, common or otherwise, against these two planthoppers. Our studies aimed to understand the defense mechanisms in rice line RP2068 against BPH and WBPH through RNA sequencing analysis of a RIL line TR3RR derived from the cross TN1 (susceptible) and RP2068 (resistant) after infestation with BPH or WBPH. Results revealed higher number of differentially expressed genes (DEGs) in BPH infested plants than in WBPH infested plants when compared with the uninfested plants. Gene ontology analysis revealed differences in plant response to the two planthoppers. These results were validated through the analysis of expression of 27 genes through semi-quantitative and quantitative real-time RT-PCR using a set of five RILs that were genetically identical but with different reaction against the two planthoppers. Rice defense against the two sympatric planthoppers: BPH and WBPH has distinct features in RP2068. Hence, a conscious combination of resistance to these two pests is essential for effective field management.

Cite as
Divya, D., Sahu, N., Reddy, P. S., Nair, S., & Bentur, J. S. (2021). RNA-sequencing reveals differentially expressed rice genes functionally associated with defense against BPH and WBPH in RILs derived from a cross between RP2068 and TN1. Rice, 14, 27. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12284-021-00470-3
Published in
Rice, vol. 14, article 27. 2021
Authors
Dhanasekar Divya, Nihar Sahu, P. Sairam Reddy, Suresh Nair, J. S. Bentur
Institutions
Agri Biotech Foundation; ICGEB; UrbanKisaan (present address of P. Sairam Reddy)
Licence
Open access, CC BY 4.0